Paid services sell convenience, not the number
New York formation is the real bill
[ Ask what your setup will cost ]
Free by law, priced by everyone standing next to it
The IRS charges nothing, by any route
| Route | Who it is for | How long |
|---|---|---|
| Online | An entity formed in the US or a US territory, with its principal place of business there, and a responsible party holding an SSN or ITIN | Minutes, the number is issued in the session |
| Fax Form SS-4 | Applicants in or outside the US, using the correct fax number | About 4 business days if you give a fax number |
| Mail Form SS-4 | Applicants in or outside the US, using the correct address | About 4 weeks |
| Phone, 267-941-1099 | A principal place of business outside the US, and the line is not toll free | The length of the call |
You can get one EIN per responsible party per business day whichever route you use, and the cap counts numbers issued rather than applications sent. A founder setting up three entities is doing it over three days whichever way they apply. The full rules are in the Instructions for Form SS-4.
What the free EIN application asks of you
The form costs attention rather than money. The current session rules and opening hours are on the IRS online application page.
What paid EIN filing services are selling
Data entry
Someone types your answers into the IRS form. The form asks perhaps a dozen questions and most of them are your own name and address.
Speed that is slower than doing it yourself
Several services advertise a 24 hour or 72 hour turnaround. The online application returns the number before you close the browser, so a 24 hour promise is slower than applying yourself.
A formation bundle
The higher prices usually include registering the entity with a state, which is a real service with a real cost. The EIN inside that bundle is still free and is often listed as though it were a line item.
A lookalike website
Some of these sites are built to read as though they were the IRS. The IRS says so itself on the page where you apply: beware of websites that charge for an EIN, and you never have to pay a fee for one.
Who gets named as the responsible party
Paying a service is just buying convenience. Worst case you overpaid for something free.
The application has to name a responsible party, meaning the person who controls the entity and its assets. That person has to be an individual rather than a company. Some services put their own details in that field, and the IRS says nominees cannot apply for an EIN.
If the wrong person is recorded, correcting it means filing Form 8822-B afterwards, and you have 60 days to report a change of responsible party. Until it is fixed, an unauthorized person stays on the IRS record for your business.
Not sure whether you need one at all?
When the fee actually buys judgment
No SSN or ITIN
A responsible party without a US identifying number cannot use the online tool at all, which is a different problem with its own route and its own page.
The entity does not exist yet
The IRS asks you to register the entity with your state before applying, and warns that skipping that step can delay the application. If the LLC is not filed, the EIN is not the thing to sort out first.
An election is going with it
Form 2553 or Form 8832 changes how the business is taxed, and both carry deadlines. That is a decision with money attached and the EIN is incidental to it.
The entity is a trust or an estate
Who the responsible party is, and whether a grantor trust needs its own EIN at all, are questions worth getting right once rather than twice.
What a New York business pays for, beyond the EIN
While the EIN is free, setting up a business in New York comes with real costs. None of them is an EIN charge, but together they are what people mean when they ask what it costs to start.
Where the money goes when a New York LLC forms around a free EIN
Articles of Organization
$200
Filed with the New York Department of State
Newspaper publication
Varies
Two newspapers, once a week for six weeks, designated by the county clerk
Certificate of Publication
$50
Filed once the newspapers give you their affidavits
Annual filing fee
$25+
Flat $25 if disregarded; a partnership pays on last year’s New York source gross income
$250 minimum before the newspaper bill, which in New York County is usually the largest line on this list.
- $200 to file Articles of Organization with the New York Department of State.
- Publication of a formation notice in two newspapers, once a week for six consecutive weeks, within 120 days of formation. This is required by section 206 of the Limited Liability Company Law, and the newspapers are designated by the county clerk for the county named on your Articles.
- $50 to file the Certificate of Publication with the Department of State once the newspapers give you their affidavits.
- An annual New York State filing fee after that, for LLCs with New York source activity. An LLC that is disregarded pays a flat $25. One treated as a partnership pays on last year’s New York source gross income, and an LLC that elected corporate treatment does not file the form at all.
The newspaper bill is the least predictable of these and, in New York County, usually the largest. It is a market price rather than a government fee, set by each county’s designated papers, and rates upstate can run well below the $200 filing fee. Add $9 every two years for the Biennial Statement the Department of State requires after formation.
How much is an EIN FAQs
Do you have to pay for an EIN number?
No. The cost to apply for an EIN is zero, and the IRS says on its own application page that you never have to pay a fee for one. Anything you are quoted is somebody’s charge for handling a free application, not a government fee.
Is there an EIN application fee for a second entity?
No. There is no EIN application fee at all, and none for a second, third or tenth entity. A sole proprietor generally needs only one EIN however many trade names they run under, although incorporating or taking on a partner does require a new one.
Can somebody else apply on my behalf?
Yes, up to a point. A third party designee can be authorized on Form SS-4 to receive the number and answer questions about the form, and that authority ends the moment the EIN is assigned. What they cannot do is stand in as the responsible party.
Why is the IRS charging me for an EIN?
It is not. The IRS charges nothing by any route, so a fee means you are on a filing service’s site rather than irs.gov. Check the address bar before you pay.
What is the cheapest way to get an EIN?
Applying yourself. Every route is free, and the online application at irs.gov returns the number in the same session.
Can I get an EIN immediately?
Yes, online. You get the number before you close the browser, if your principal place of business is in the US and the responsible party holds an SSN or ITIN. Fax takes about four business days and mail about four weeks.
[ Tell us what you are starting ]
12+ years
serving NYC
150,000+
returns filed
5 star
Google and Yelp
Open
evenings and weekends
On custom plans, and on getting it right the first time
“Each person that reaches out to us gets a custom quote and a custom proposal for their exact tax situation. So each person that approaches us has the opportunity to speak with an adviser to put together a custom plan.”
George Dimov, CPA
“Incredible service! Saved me so much money and helped me navigate being a new business owner!”
Prerna Menon
Google review
Know the real number before you start
